The Center for Public Integrity released a report this week about the judicial proceedings and consequences for accused sexual assault perpetrators on college and university campuses. Not surprisingly, the group found that the consequences alleged assailants face are minimal. Expulsion is rare and only done in the cases when the judicial board believes that he or she poses an ongoing threat. Such judicial boards admit that their goal is not punishment but rather education. But even this re-education seems minimal and as we have documented in several of the sexual assault cases we have covered, the institution often takes very few steps to minimize the emotional and potential physical distress to the victim. This leaves alleged victims having to deal with on-campus encounters with both the perpetrator and other unsympathetic parties. While the alleged assailant may receive a suspension, it is often the victim who will leave the school permanently.
Schools seem betwixt and between about these issues. They clearly are not serving their students well with this quasi justice system. And they would rather not be dealing with these issues at all. But the criminal justice system is not the most conducive place for dealing with on-campus sexual assault crimes either. Cases frequently are not strong enough for prosecutors to take on.
So it seems that neither the institutions they attend nor the justice system they have access to are serving these (mostly) female students well--or (barely) at all.
An interdisciplinary resource for news, legal developments, commentary, and scholarship about Title IX, the federal statute prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex in federally funded schools.
Bad investigations
The more I learn about the ins and outs of Title IX (and Title VI) investigations, the more pessimistic I become about the ability of these...
-
Three former employees of Feather River College (Quincy, California) pressed their Title IX retaliation claims at a two-week hearing before...
-
In the wake of the Quinnipiac case, in which it seemed that the university somewhat spitefully cut men's track and field when it was tol...
-
The NCAA has come out with a very clear position on sexual relationships between coaches and student-athletes. They are wrong. They are a ...